Think of the Oscars, the Grammies, the Webbys - none of these are each just one award. They all have several categories. There are several qualities and roles to look out for, and you can analyze your projects in very much the same way.
Think of what qualities are most important to you. For example, if you make Flash games, break it down into Best Gameplay, Best Graphics, Best Sound, Funniest Story, Most Interesting Scenario, and so on. Customize the awards to what you value.